arpae-cover
arpae1-0
arpae1-1
arpae1-2
arpae1-3
arpae1-5
arpae1-6
previous arrow
next arrow
arpae-cover
arpae1-0
arpae1-1
arpae1-2
arpae1-3
arpae1-5
arpae1-6
previous arrow
next arrow

3D-Printed Carbon Absorbing High-Performance Building Structure

Booth 1014 at ARPA-E Summit 2022

Authors

Masoud Akbarzadeh (PI), Architecture, University of Pennsylvania
Dorit Aviv (co-PI), Architecture, University of Pennsylvania
Peter Psarras (co-PI), Architecture, University of Pennsylvania
Shu Yang (co-PI), Materials Science and Engineering, University of Pennsylvania
Mohammad Bolhassani (co-PI), Architecture, The City College of New York
Zheng O’Neil (co-PI), Mechanical Engineering, Texas A&M University
Billie Faircloth (co-PI), KieranTimberlake

Maximilian E. Ororbia, Hua Chai, Teng Teng, Yefan Zhi, Yi Yang, Xiang Zhang, Zherui Wang, Kunhao Yu, Sohee Nah (University of Pennsylvania), Youngsik Choi (Texas A&M University), Ryan Welch (KieranTimberlake)

Project Date

2022-

Acknowledgements

This research is funded by the Advanced Research Projects Agency – Energy (ARPA-E) of U.S. Department of Energy (DE-FOA-0002625 2625-1538).

Technology Summary

An innovative design strategy for a carbon negative
building system.

  • A high-performance, prefabricated, funicular floor structure with minimized mass and maximized surface area for carbon absorption.
  • A novel carbon absorbing concrete mixture.
  • Concrete 3D printing technology with post-tensioned prefabricated parts to reduce construction waste and enhance structural performance.
  • Using additional bio-based carbon storing materials in secondary structural systems.
  • Exploiting thermal mass, adaptive envelope, and electrified building systems with heat pumps to reduce operational energy over the building’s life cycle.
  • A Building Information Modeling (BIM)-integrated life cycle analysis (LCA) feedback loop.
  • The combined strategies ensure carbon negativity on a cradle-to-gate and cradle-to-grave basis.
arpae2-0
arpae2-1
arpae2-2-1
arpae2-2-2
previous arrow
next arrow
arpae2-0
arpae2-1
arpae2-2-1
arpae2-2-2
previous arrow
next arrow

3D Printed Prefabrication

Minimized construction materials and maximized surface area.

  • A high-performance, prefabricated structure with minimized mass and maximized surface area.
  • Utilizing 3D-printed concrete technology and pre-stressed prefabricated components to diminish construction waste.
  • Employing polyhedral graphic statics techniques to create a spaceframe-like shape that corresponds with a related force diagram.
  • The angles and dimensions of the tension elements in the lower chord are fine-tuned to evenly distribute force, allowing for the integration of a continuous tensile component into the system.
  • Our rapid and clear local optimization process enhances completed designs by transforming them into self-supporting geometries, rather than constraining them from the outset.
  • By examining the geometry via a systematic sequence of toolpaths, it accommodates the predetermined printing resolution while maintaining the shell structure’s consistent thickness and curvature continuity.

Efficient Structural System

Minimized construction materials and maximized surface area.

  • Compared with conventional beam elements, our innovative system shows elastic behavior while all the beams experience plastic deformation.
  • The resulting printed elements are strong enough to resist the applied loads with minimum stress and deflection.

Carbon Absorbing Concrete Mixture

Efficient, printable, and durable carbon capture material.

  • Incorporating CO2-absorbing materials in the concrete mixture to increase surface areas and bicarbonate uptake.
  • The optimized concrete ink achieved performance characteristics, including mechanical strength, surface area, CO2 storage, printability, and buildability.
  • Achieved compressive strength up to 46 MPa.
  • Average specific surface area: 15 m2/g.
  • CO2 storage up to 0.16 kg CO2/kg concrete.
  • Possess excellent shear-thinning properties and buildability for 3D printing.
arpae2-3
arpae2-4
arpae2-5
arpae2-5-0
arpae2-5-1
arpae2-6
previous arrow
next arrow
arpae2-3
arpae2-4
arpae2-5
arpae2-5-0
arpae2-5-1
arpae2-6
previous arrow
next arrow

Operational Energy Reduction

Bridges active and passive design approaches.

  • Acting as an excellent thermal capacitor, the lightweight 3d-printed concrete floor design stores heat and provides inertia against extreme temperature fluctuations. This in turn reduces building operational energy consumption and improves occupant thermal comfort.
  • With expanded concrete surface area exposure, heat transfer rate and thermal storage potential increase while the material volume remains unchanged.
  • On an annual basis, by adding thermal mass with expanded surface area exposure, our preliminary analysis achieves 812 additional comfort hours in the core zone alone during the occupied hours of a medium office building in a hot-dry climate.
  • Heat pump systems provide heating and cooling via radiant hydronic systems embedded in the building thermal mass.
  • Heat pump systems operate with low-exergy heat sources and renewable energy sources.

Lifecycle Assessment

Iterative modeling of pathway to net zero GHG emissions.

  • The Proposed System is expected to reduce building weight, provide passive and active thermal exchange, and afford space for system routing.
  • These features could offer savings in several forms: reduced foundations, reduced mechanical equipment, energy savings, and lower floor-to-floor height, which in turn would yield savings in envelope materials and finishes.
  • Carbonation is an essential performance attribute of the proposed system, so direct lab measurements of CO₂-uptake rates for alternative mix designs under various environmental conditions will be necessary to develop estimates of how elementary CO₂ flows respond to mix-design, mass, exposed surface area, environmental conditions, and end-of-life scenario.

Vision: Integrated Carbon Negativity

Capture full co-benefits of novel systems.

  • Reduction in concrete volume and improvements in mix design will yield an 85% reduction in A1-A3 GWP for building superstructure, relative to best-in-class incumbent reinforced concrete construction practice.
  • Use of off-site-printed modular structural system will substantially reduce emissions from transportation and reducing erection time to site (A4) and on-site construction (A5) through lower weight and elimination of formwork.
  • Integration of mechanical systems within structure will eliminate need for mechanical plenums, leading to material savings in ductwork and finish materials, as well as reducing floor-to-floor height.
  • Lower floor-to-floor-height will lead to material savings in vertical envelope, partitions, and building cores, as well as energy savings from envelope gains and losses.
  • Reduced building weight will lead to material savings in foundations.
  • Incorporation of bio-based and carbon negative building materials for interior and building envelope assemblies will be curated to offset remaining emissions.